Your shopping cart

Educational Law & Policy

Supreme Court Leaves California's Implicit-Bias Continuing Medical Education Requirement in Place

Cameron
Cameron
November 17, 2026
5 min read
Supreme Court Leaves California's Implicit-Bias Continuing Medical Education Requirement in Place
New To Education free registration banner inviting visitors to join the learning community. Learn, Connect, Grow. Sponsored

Editorial Note

On November 16, 2026, the Supreme Court declined to review Khatibi v. Yip, No. 25-1240. That denial leaves the lower-court result undisturbed, but it is not a Supreme Court merits ruling approving every aspect of California's approach to professional education.

The case presents competing arguments about whether the state may require particular educational content in continuing medical education courses. California emphasizes its authority to regulate medical licensing and protect patients. Challengers argue that the requirement improperly compels private instructors to communicate a contested viewpoint.

Justice Clarence Thomas, joined by Justice Samuel Alito, dissented from the denial of review. Justice Neil Gorsuch also indicated that he would have heard the case. Their positions should not be mistaken for a majority Supreme Court ruling.

This article is educational and informational and does not provide legal or professional licensing advice.

Bottom Line

California's existing implicit-bias curriculum requirement for continuing medical education remains in place following the Supreme Court's November 16 decision not to hear a First Amendment challenge.

Three justices expressed support for taking the case, but the Court did not agree to review it. The underlying California law was not newly enacted on November 16; the substantive event that day was the Supreme Court's disposition of the petition.

What Happened

California requires licensed physicians to complete approved continuing medical education as part of the licensing framework. A state law adopted in 2019 introduced an implicit-bias curriculum requirement applicable beginning in 2022.

Physician and course instructor Azadeh Khatibi and the organization Do No Harm challenged that requirement. They argued that compelling instructors to cover the state-prescribed subject violated constitutional protections for private speech.

The lower courts rejected the challenge under their analysis of government speech and professional regulation. On November 16, the Supreme Court declined to hear the appeal.

What the Law Says

California Business and Professions Code Section 2190.1 addresses the educational purposes and content of approved medical education courses. Its implicit-bias provisions require qualifying courses to address how bias can influence medical perceptions, decisions or disparities in patient outcomes.

The dispute was not simply about whether bias can exist in healthcare. It concerned the constitutional boundary between a state setting conditions for professional education credits and the rights of private instructors who disagree with particular course requirements.

The Ninth Circuit treated qualifying continuing medical education within California's regulatory framework as government speech for purposes of the challenge. The dissenting justices questioned that reasoning and warned against equating extensive regulation with government control over a speaker's message.

What This Means for Educators and Training Providers

Continuing medical education providers working within California's licensing system should continue reviewing the applicable requirements rather than assuming the Supreme Court removed them.

Course designers can examine how to address mandated subjects using accurate evidence, appropriate clinical examples and clear learning objectives. Strong professional education should distinguish established findings, disputed evidence, ethical responsibilities and the limits of individual studies.

Universities that provide licensed-professional training should also pay attention. Although this case concerns medicine, it illustrates questions that can arise whenever governments require specific curriculum content within professional credentialing programs.

What This Does Not Mean

The Court did not create a nationwide requirement for implicit-bias training in every profession. Nor did the Court issue a new majority opinion holding that every state-mandated professional education topic is constitutional.

California's requirement and the legal reasoning in the lower courts have their own defined scope. Other professional development programs may operate under different statutes and accreditation arrangements.

Bigger Picture

Professional education frequently involves mandatory topics such as ethics, infection prevention, patient safety and legal compliance. Regulators maintain that such requirements protect the public and ensure practitioners understand essential professional responsibilities.

Critics of mandated curricular content caution that the state should not use licensing authority to dictate ideological agreement. The distinction between teaching about a subject and compelling a particular viewpoint remains central to this debate.

For course providers, instructional quality matters alongside legal compliance. Requirements are more useful when learners can examine credible evidence, understand professional responsibilities and apply the material to practical decisions.

What Happens Next

California training providers should monitor guidance from their licensing and accrediting bodies. Future lawsuits in other contexts may examine where government regulation of professional learning crosses into compelled private expression.

Any proposed legislative change should be evaluated separately from the Supreme Court's November 16 denial of review.

Why This Matters

Professional development affects real decisions made by physicians, educators and other licensed professionals. The way mandated subjects are taught influences whether training promotes informed judgment or becomes a procedural exercise.

This case highlights the need to protect both meaningful professional standards and a legally sound approach to educational speech.

Key Takeaways

  • The Supreme Court denied review in Khatibi v. Yip on November 16.

  • California's existing continuing medical education requirement remains in place.

  • Three justices supported Supreme Court review.

  • The Court did not issue a new majority opinion resolving the constitutional debate.

  • Course providers should distinguish educational requirements from assertions of compelled personal belief.

Frequently Asked Questions

Was California's law passed on November 16?

No. The statutory requirement predates the Supreme Court's 2026 action.

Did the Supreme Court rule that implicit-bias education is constitutionally required?

No. It declined to hear the challenge.

Does this decision apply to K–12 teachers?

The case concerns California's continuing medical education framework, not a general rule for K–12 teacher training.

Final Thoughts

The ruling preserves the existing outcome while leaving broader questions about professional regulation and educational speech open for debate. It should be described precisely as a denial of Supreme Court review, not as a nationwide decision about every form of required workplace training.

The most productive response for education providers is to combine careful legal compliance with intellectually rigorous, evidence-based instruction.

Related Articles

Texas Tech professors challenge restrictions on teaching race and gender

https://newtoeducation.com/view-blog/texas-tech-professors-sue-over-restrictions-on-teaching-race-and-gender-6a5de3d7e9913

Federal civil-rights regulation and the standard for proving school discrimination

https://newtoeducation.com/view-blog/new-federal-civil-rights-rule-could-make-school-discrimination-harder-to-prove-6a62ea0e2d623

Support New To Education

Support educational reporting that separates legal decisions, proposals and established requirements:

https://newtoeducation.com/support-us

Explore New To Education on Mobile

Explore educational resources through the New To Education iPhone app, subject to App Store availability and age requirements.

https://apps.apple.com/us/app/new-to-education/id6792293782

Sources

Supreme Court — Justice Thomas's dissent and November 16 disposition

https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/26pdf/25-1240_9ol1.pdf

Cornell Legal Information Institute — Case text

https://www.law.cornell.edu/supremecourt/text/25-1240

The Hill reporting, republished by AOL — November 16, 2026

https://www.aol.com/articles/supreme-court-won-t-review-150252000.html

New To Education web development subscription banner advertising custom website plans with responsive design, SEO-ready setup and fast turnaround. Sponsored

Join the Discussion

Have thoughts on this article? Join the NTE Community to share your perspective and connect with others.

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Be the first to share a thought.

Cameron

Written by

Cameron

Founder of New To Education, building a global platform connecting education, business, and opportunity.

New To Education resume writing subscription banner advertising resume updates, ATS optimization, LinkedIn review and cover letter support. Sponsored
New To Education Chat With Tutors subscription banner advertising flexible monthly conversation support, 4, 8, or unlimited chat sessions. Sponsored

Support Our Platform

Enjoyed this article? Help us continue providing quality education and free content to learners worldwide.

Minimum: $1.00

Never miss an update

Subscribe to our newsletter and get the latest articles delivered straight to your inbox.

No spam · Unsubscribe anytime

Stay in the loop

Get the latest articles, tutorials, and news
delivered straight to your inbox.

Weekly updates No spam, ever Unsubscribe anytime
Support Us
Help Us Grow

Love learning with us? Help us continue providing quality education and free content to learners worldwide.

$

You're subscribed!

Thank you for joining us. Watch your inbox for
fresh articles and updates.


Stay in the loop

Get the latest articles, tutorials, and news
delivered straight to your inbox.

Weekly updates No spam, ever Unsubscribe anytime
Support Us
Help Us Grow

Love learning with us? Help us continue providing quality education and free content to learners worldwide.

$

You're subscribed!

Thank you for joining us. Watch your inbox for
fresh articles and updates.

NewToEd Assistant

Always here to help